I test coffee gear for a living, so I use water on everything from obscure grocery store bricks to the most unusual. I get asked about expensive coffee all the time. Is it worth it? Yes, but a $50 bag of coffee will taste worse than a $5 bag if you don’t have the right gear to brew it.
Internet coffee tends to bleed into arguments about trivial things. But when it comes to the difference between commodity coffee and specialty coffee, it’s not a complete mistake. It is an important difference in terms of cultivation, processing, and roasting method.
Get a FREE first bag of coffee from our friends at Atlas Coffee Club when you sign up. Enter your email to receive the deal.
Let’s examine the details of why these bags are priced differently, and why choosing the most expensive bag off the shelf can be a bad decision for your kitchen.
Price Level Classification
Here’s what you get for the average price range before we look at the extremes.
| Price range (12oz bag) | Availability and traceability | Standard Roast Level | Characteristic Tolerance | Cost per cup (15g serving) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5 (Materials) | Unknown bunches include, usually arabica and robusta. | It’s Very Dark | Top (covered by grilling process) | ~$0.22 |
| $20 (Sweet Special) | Single origin or farm specific blends. It is fully traceable. | Light to Medium | Very Low | ~$0.88 |
| $50 (Competition/Regular) | Certain micro-lots, rare varieties (like Geisha), experimental processing. | Very Light | Zero | ~$2.20 |
The $5 Bag: Commodity Reality
A $5 bag of coffee is the result of a lot of agricultural work. The coffee beans come from large regional farms that often include a combination of low-quality Arabica beans and inexpensive Robusta beans to keep costs down.
The defining feature of this price range is the level of roasting. Beans at this level are taken by black burners the most. They do this to hide mistakes. Young roasts will taste bad if the beans are damaged by insects or picked before they are ripe. A fatty and dark roast will dry up the flavor. So you’ll get ash, dark chocolate, and a lot of bitterness.
There is an opposite to this method. Dark roasts are much easier to break down. The heat caused significant damage to the bean structure. It is easy for water to break down compounds. You can use this coffee with a cheap $20 drip machine with poor temperature control, and still get a consistent cup. It’s very forgiving.
$50 Purse: Competitive Division
At $50 for a standard bag, you’re entering the market for specials. You no longer buy a generic combination. You buy a specific strain, grown in a specific area, and processed using highly controlled methods such as anaerobic fermentation.
These beans are very dense. Rosés are kept very light to preserve the delicate notes of flowers and fruits found in the seeds. This creates a mechanical problem for the home seller. Light roasts are notoriously difficult to pull off.
If you grind a $50 light roast with a cheap blade grinder and brew it in a regular coffee maker, the water will pass through the uneven stones. The resulting cup will taste like sour vegetable juice. The coffee maker just can’t get the water hot enough, and the grinder can’t create the right particle size to extract the desired flavor from the dense beans.
To get your money’s worth out of this coffee, you’ll need a grinder with precise burr alignment, freshly boiled water, and you’ll need a good method.
Law of Diminishing Returns
To improve your coffee experience at home, you must know where your money is going.
Jumping from $5 to $20 is the biggest jump in quality you can make. You go from a blemished, burnt bean to a well-filtered, well-roasted coffee. This is where you find the best single origin beans. The flavors are different. You can taste the difference between washed Ethiopian coffee and naturally processed Brazilian beans. This is a great place to drink every day.
The price increase from $20 to $50 tells a different story. It’s becoming less about buying the \”better morning cup\” and more about scarcity. He supports novel fermentation techniques. You are buying agricultural produce with limited yields and diminishing returns. Once you pass the $20 mark, returns decrease significantly.
Pragmatic Buying Advice
Don’t buy higher quality coffee than your equipment, so buy beans that match your gear.
- If you’re using a regular automatic drip machine, stick to $10 to $15, and buy medium or dark roasts. Your machine won’t turn out light roasts well, so there’s no reason to spend too much.
- If you own a good burr grinder and a reset, the $18 to $25 bag is your workhorse. Your gear can handle light and medium roasts, allowing you to taste the characteristics of the origin.
- If you have a high-end espresso machine or precision flat burrs, you have the equipment needed to shell out a $50 bag. Buy it if you want to try unusual varieties and have time to dial the grind.
Marketing the beans may try to convince you that buying a premium bean will turn a cup of coffee into something great. This is not true. Buy the best beans your grinder is capable of and ignore the rest.