Waterproof Running Shoes: Pros and Cons

Trail running shoes with waterproof linings are a popular choice for hikers, backpackers, and everyday outdoor enthusiasts who want protection in wet conditions without carrying hiking boots. But are waterproof trail runners always the best option? This article explains the main advantages and disadvantages so you can decide what suits your needs and the situations you expect to face.

What does “waterproof” mean?

Most waterproof trail runners use a breathable, waterproof membrane, usually Gore-Tex or a similar technology, stretched between the upper and the shoe. The membrane keeps liquid water out while allowing some internal moisture (sweat) to escape. Some models also have a water repellent (DWR) treatment on the outer garment to make the water bead up and roll off before it gets inside.

Benefits

1. Keeps feet dry in wet conditions. The most obvious benefit is protection from rain, water, rivers, and wet grass. On wet trails or during sudden showers, waterproof trail runners prevent outdoor moisture from soaking your socks and footbed. Dry feet reduce the blisters, discomfort, and chills that come with wet shoes.
2. It is better in cold and wet places. When temperatures are low, wet feet lose heat quickly. Waterproof membranes add a layer of insulation against wind-driven rain and snowmelt. In fall, winter, or early spring in wet areas, waterproof shoes can help keep feet warm.
3. You are ready to go. For many users, a waterproof pair is a “set it and forget it” solution—no need to change shoes when the morning looks gray, or the forecast calls for showers. This convenience is perfect for riders, hikers, and anyone who wants reliable protection without controlling the choice of footwear.
4. Protection from debris and mud. The extra lining and DWR-treated uppers often make waterproof trail runners easy to clean after a muddy hike. The membrane can also reduce water infiltration when entering shallow streams or walking on dew-covered grass.
5. Long lasting construction. Most waterproof models are built with reinforced upper layers, taped seams, and durable materials, which can translate to longer life in harsh conditions compared to lightweight waterproof shoes.

Evil

1. Reduced breathing. All waterproof membranes limit how much moisture can escape from inside the shoe. During strenuous activity or in warm weather, the sweat produced by your feet may not evaporate quickly enough, leading to stiff, dry socks inside, and a greater risk of blisters. In hot, dry conditions, a breathable, waterproof shoe usually keeps the feet comfortable.
2. It will dry out a bit if it gets wet. If water gets in through the tongue, collar, or because the lining is worn and broken, the water trapped in a waterproof shoe takes longer to dry than in a mesh shoe. That can be a problem on multi-day trips where you need the shoes to dry between uses.
3. It’s tough and tough. Waterproof membranes and reinforced materials around them often add weight and reduce flexibility compared to lightweight, fully mesh trail runners. That extra weight can be important for long walks or fast runs where every ounce affects fatigue and performance.
4. High costs. Waterproof models often cost more than waterproof models due to the technology and membrane construction. If you rarely deal with wet conditions, the extra cost may not be forgivable.
5. A false sense of security in deep water crossings. Waterproof trail runners keep outside water out only up to the top of the shoe. If you’re wading deep streams or entering standing water above the collar, water will enter regardless. For deep or prolonged immersion, waterproof boots with high tops, or quick-release, waterproof shoes that you can dry easily, may be a better choice.

When to choose waterproof trail runners

• Wet weather or seasons: If you’re constantly hiking or running in rainy, snowy, or generally wet areas, waterproof trail runners offer comfort and visible protection.
• Cold weather use: In cool to cold temperatures where moisture quickly freezes on your feet, waterproof models help retain warmth.
• Commuting and mixed urban/outdoor use: If you’re moving from pavement to trails and want constant protection from puddles and slush, waterproof shoes are an easy choice.
• Short day trips where layover time is not an issue: For a one-day visit or a quick return, shortness of breath is not a minor problem.

When to choose waterproof trail runners

• Hot weather jogging or walking: Breathing is very important; The mesh is a high wick and wicks away sweat much better.
• Multi-day backpacking in variable conditions where quick drying is essential: Waterproof or quick-drying shoes dry quickly when soaked, helping to prevent long-term wetness.
• Light or ultralight settings: If weight and flexibility are priorities for a race, fast pack, or long-distance run, waterproof shoes often save weight and increase comfort.
• Always crossing deep water: Shoes designed for quick release or sandals may be safer and more practical than relying on a waterproof membrane.

Helpful hints

• Use appropriate socks: Merino wool or synthetic socks manage moisture and reduce odor even when the outer layers are wet.
• Keep DWR and lining: Reapply the DWR treatment as it ages, and follow the manufacturer’s care instructions to extend the life of the membrane.
• Check in your circumstances: If possible, try a short visit in fair weather to check comfort and breathability before committing.

Bottom line

Waterproof trail running shoes offer clear advantages in wet, cold, or mixed conditions, providing comfort and protection. But they trade off breathability, weight, and drying speed. Choose based on the weather, the intensity of the activity, and whether keeping feet dry from outside humidity or preventing internal perspiration is your priority.

SectionHiker never accepts payment for gear reviews or editorial submissions. Help us keep checking and writing unsponsored and independent gear reviews, hiking and backpacking FAQs, and free hiking guides.